Bilateral monopoly
A bilateral monopoly is a market structure consisting of both a monopoly (a single seller) and a monopsony (a single buyer).[1]
Overview
In a standard monopoly structure, the monopolist sells to multiple buyers with no market power, thereby giving the monopolist the power to set their own price and quantity to optimise their profits. The same power imbalance occurs in a monopsony where the monopsonist is the only buyer in a market of many sellers[2].
A bilateral monopoly requires the cooperation of both the monopolist and monopsonist to maximise their respective profits. Arthur Lyon Bowley argued that both parties follow a price leadership strategy in which the seller sets the price to maximise their profits and the buyer responds by setting the quantity to maximise their profits[3]. This strategy can be analysed using the theory of Nash bargaining games, and market price and output will be determined by forces like bargaining power of both buyer and seller, with a final price settling in between the two sides' points of maximum profit. A bilateral monopoly model is often used in situations where the switching costs of both sides are prohibitively high.
The lack of alternatives within a given market gives way for vertical integration where the monopolist and monopsonist merge to control both upstream and downstream entities[4]. An example of a monopolist using vertical integration to maximise their control is Standard Oil in the United States which is best known for its monopoly of oil production and refinery in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century[5]. The market power that Standard Oil acquired from its monopoly of oil production allowed it to exert unreasonable control over the railroads used to transport their oil. Standard Oil forced the railroads to exclusively service Standard Oil's business and to lower their prices otherwise Standard Oil would pull all of their business from that railroad company. In this case, the bilateral monopoly quickly became a structure of vertical integration with Standard Oil being both the monopolist and monopsonist.
Examples
- A labor union (a monopolist supplier of labor) faces a single employer in a factory town (a monopsonist of employment)[6].
- The United States Navy is the only buyer of nuclear-powered aircraft carriers in the United States, and Huntington Ingalls Industries is the only seller due to the United States Department of Defense only issuing a license to Huntington Ingalls Industries[7].
- The South Korean economy has also been called out for being one entire bilateral monopoly due to the existence of Chaebols where giant mega-corporations control both the sale of products (e.g. consumer goods only manufactured by Samsung Electronics or LG or cars manufactured by or in a partnership with Kia/Hyundai or Renault Samsung Motors) as well as being the sole employer of most people besides the government.[8]
- Lignite (brown coal) mines and lignite power stations are a bilateral monopoly as the cost of transportation of lignite prohibits long distance transport. As such, power stations are located next to lignite mines and are the only buyer of lignite[9].
References
- Mark Hirschey, Fundamentals of Managerial Economics, Cengage Learning, 2008, pp. 474
- Blair, Roger D.; Sokol, D. Daniel (2015). The Oxford Handbook of International Antitrust Economics, Volume 1 (illustrated ed.). Oxford University Press. p. 365. ISBN 0199859191.
- Kalinowski, Sławomir (2015). "Price Discount for the Increased Order as a Cooperative Game in Bilateral Monopoly". Economics & Society. 8 (3): 108–118.
- Lyon Bowley, Arthur (1 December 1928). "Bilateral Monopoly". The Economic Journal. 38 (152): 651–658.
- Priest, George L. (9 May 2012). "RETHINKING THE ECONOMIC BASIS OF THE STANDARD OIL REFINING MONOPOLY: DOMINANCE AGAINST COMPETING CARTELS". Southern California Law Review. 85: 508.
- "Bilateral Monopoly". Economics Help. Retrieved 3 May 2022.
- Science Theory. "Bilateral monopoly". HKT Consulting. Retrieved 3 May 2022.
- https://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=youtu.be&v=jRzysFhyZ8Y Economy of South Korea - Economics Explained - via YouTube - retrieved 6 September 2020 - released 1 March 2020
- Science Theory. "Bilateral monopoly". HKT Consulting. Retrieved 3 May 2022.