SoundSpel

SoundSpel is a regular and mostly phonemic English-language spelling reform proposal. Written with the 26-letter ISO basic Latin alphabet, it is fully compatible with the QWERTY keyboard. SoundSpel can represent dialectal pronunciation, but it was originally based on General American English. Dating back to 1910,[1] SoundSpel was developed "in response to the widely held conviction that English spelling is more complex than it needs to be."[2] The American Literacy Council has endorsed the reform[3] because English speakers can easily read it.[4]

Some common English words containing traditional spelling's infamous tetragraph -ough-, written in SoundSpel.

History

In 1910, philologist Alexander John Ellis played a major role in developing a system now known as "Classic New Spelling". Walter Ripman and William Archer wrote the first dictionary of the system, New Spelling (NuSpelling), which was republished in 1941 by the Simplified Spelling Society.

In the early 1960s, Sir James Pitman developed the Initial Teaching Alphabet (I.T.A. or i.t.a.) which would become one of SoundSpel's predecessors.[5]

In 1969, Godfrey Dewey improved upon Ripman's and Archer's work, producing World English Spelling. Dewey and Edward Rondthaler, a prominent typesetter and CEO of the International Typeface Corporation, corresponded from 1971.

In 1986, the American Language Academy published the Dictionary of Simplified American Spelling, a book written by Rondthaler and Edward Lias. It calls for the improvement of English spelling, with clearer rules and better grapheme/phoneme correspondence. Its guidelines are less strictly phonemic than Classic New Spelling; for instance, the sounds /θ/ and /ð/ are represented by the grapheme ⟨th⟩ as to follow traditional spelling. Classic New Spelling opts instead for ⟨th⟩ and ⟨dh⟩, respectively.

The system was further reformed from 1987 on and became SoundSpel.

Description

Phonetics

Graphemes here are matched to their phonemic equivalents via the International Phonetic Alphabet. Examples in SoundSpel are accompanied by italicized traditional spellings.

SpellingMajor values (IPA)Examples of major valuesMinor values (IPA)Examples of minor values
a[lower-alpha 1][lower-alpha 2]/æ/, /ə/ (final)sat, stigma (sat, stigma)/ə/, /ɔː/ago (ago), tall (tall)
e[lower-alpha 1]/ɛ/set (set), frend (friend)/ə/, // (prefixes), /ɪ/, /i/*belownovel (novel), jeografy (geography), event (event)
i[lower-alpha 1][lower-alpha 3]/ɪ/, // (final)did (did), hi (hi, high)/ə/, /ɪ/, /i/*beloweezily (easily), trivial (trivial)
o[lower-alpha 1][lower-alpha 3][lower-alpha 2]/ɒ/, // (final)dot (dot), lo (lo, low)/ə/, /ɔː/lemon (lemon), cross (cross)
u/ʌ/cut (cut), stun (stun)
SpellingIPAExamples
ae//S/sundae (Sunday, sundae)
ee//see (see), eeven (even)
ie//diess (dice), ie (eye, aye)
oe//oever (over), doe (doe)
ue/juː/cue (cue, queue), abuez (abuse)
SpellingIPAExamples
aa/ɑː/laat (lot), waach (watch)
au, aw[lower-alpha 4][lower-alpha 2]/ɔː/maul (maul), saw (saw)
oi/ɔɪ/coin (coin), toi (toy)
oo//moon (moon), oober (uber)
ou, ow[lower-alpha 4]//our (hour/our), tower (tower)
uu/ʊ/guud (good), wuuman (woman)
SpellingIPAExamples
ar/ɑːr/bar (bar), ark (arc, ark, arch)
er/ɜːr/, /ər/merj (merge), biter (bitter)
or/ɔːr/befor (before), lor (lore)
SpellingIPAExamples
arr/ær/marry (marry), barrier (barrier)
err/ɛr/declerr (declare), errand (errand)
orr/ɒr/sorry (sorry), qorry (quarry)
ur[lower-alpha 5]/ʊər/alur (allure), bonjur (bonjour)
air/ɛər/flair (flair, flare), chair (chair)
eer/ɪər/beer (beer), endeer (endear)
uer/jʊər/cuer (cure), secuer (secure)
SpellingMajor values (IPA)Examples of major valuesMinor values (IPA)Examples of minor values
b/b/bat (bat), loeb (lobe)
c/k[lower-alpha 6]/k/cat, kik (cat, kick)
ch//ich (itch), chiken (chicken)
d/d/od (odd), det (debt)
f/f/foeny (phony), ofis (office)
g/ɡ/gorjus (gorgeous), oeger (ogre)
h/h/hat (hat), ahed (ahead)[ç]huej (huge), Huey (Huey)
j//juj (judge), jiraf (giraffe)
kh[lower-alpha 7]/x/, [x], [χ]lokh (loch), aakh/okh (ach/och)
l/l/, [l], [ɫ], [l̩][lower-alpha 8]litl (little), stil (still)
m/m/, [m], [m̩][lower-alpha 8]munky (monkey), rithm (rhythm)
n/n/ [n], [n̩][lower-alpha 8]niet (night), buton (button)/ŋ/[lower-alpha 9]ink (ink), tranqil (tranquil), linx (lynx)
ng/ŋ/eeting (eating), rong (wrong)
p/p/peper (pepper), mop (mop)
q/kw/erthqaek (earthquake), qel (quell)
r/r/, [ɹ]red (red, read), ratatooy (ratatouille)
s/s/sik (sick), los (loss)/z/*belowraes (rays), Occam's (Occam's)
sh/ʃ/shed (shed), ishoo (issue)
t/t/, [tʰ], [t], [ɾ], [ʔ]tatl (tattle), waaterspouts (waterspouts)
th[lower-alpha 10]/θ/thin (thin), thru (through)/ð/this (this), neether/niether (neither)
v/v/uven (oven), vaxseen (vaccine)
w/w/wor (war), wam! (wham!)
wh/hw/whi (why w/o merger), whiet (white)
x[lower-alpha 11]/ks/box (box), iebex (ibex)/gz/, /k/exist (exist), oxsen (oxen)
y/j/yes (yes), loiyer/laayer (lawyer)/ɪ/, /i/*belowfuny (funny), raedyo (radio)
z/z/zoo (zoo), buz (buzz)
zh/ʒ/azher (azure), zhaanra (genre)

Rules

SoundSpel's rules have changed considerably over time; listed below are generally the most recent guidelines. Notable former rules that have become obsolete or otherwise optional are also listed. The Dictionary of Simplified American Spelling notes that SoundSpel, at least in its 1986 form, was not a fait accompli. It reads: "We are now at the point where further fine tuning [of SoundSpel] is appropriate. Recommendations are welcome from all—phoneticians, linguists, educators, publishers, those with a special interest in the subject, and, very importantly, the public at large."[18]

False diphthongs

If a pair of two vowel letters—such as ea—do not match a SoundSpel digraph, then the syllable ends with the first vowel, as in react (read as re-act), jeenius (genius), and creaetiv (creative). In words with three or more vowels letters, the syllable ends with the first digraph. For example, flooid (fluid, read as floo-id rather than flo-oid) hieest (highest), inueendo (innuendo), paeabl (payable), and evalueaet (evaluate).[6]

Hyphens and syllable breaks

In SoundSpel, hyphens have many uses. They separate adjacent letters that might otherwise be mistaken for a digraph. Examples include: ⟨nk⟩ in man-kiend (mankind), ⟨rr⟩ in for-runer (forerunner) ⟨sh⟩ in dis-harten (dishearten), ⟨th⟩ in pent-hous (penthouse), and ⟨wh⟩ in cow-hand (cowhand). Where "n-g" would be visually awkward, two n's mark the close of the syllable, as in enngaej (engage), enngulf (engulf), and enngraev (engrave). In fact, enngaej accounts for more than half of the double-n's frequency. Hyphens are also used to indicate that the letter ⟨y⟩ is a consonant beginning a syllable (barn-yard, mid-yeer for mid-year) rather than a vowel ending a syllable (handyman, apreeshyaet for appreciate), as the latter occurs much more frequently. Where -y would be visually awkward (as in mil-yon for million and compan-yon for companion), two l's or two n's mark the end of the syllable, hence millyon and compannyon. Excepting the preceding rules and those regarding /ɔː/, all doubled consonants have a consonant break in between them, including meelles (mealless), unnumberd (unnumbered), buukkeeper (bookkeeper), and cattael (cattail). [16] These also often represent geminates.

When a hyphen follows a prefix, it indicates that the vowel is long (e.g., co-ed, re-arm, bi-lateral). An adjacent preceding vowel is also long (bio-, neo-). Compare jeo-sentrik (geocentric) and jeolojy (geology). In jeo-sentrik, the ⟨e⟩ is long because of the following long ⟨o⟩, and the ⟨o⟩ is long because of the hyphen. In jeolojy, only the ⟨e⟩ is long. When ⟨ar⟩ and ⟨or⟩ are followed by a stressed vowel (e.g. maroon, memorandum), the ⟨a⟩ and ⟨o⟩ are pronounced as /ʌ/, and the ⟨r⟩ begins a new syllable.

Schwa and schwi

There are no changes in the spelling of the schwa (/ə/) sound in the unstressed syllables of words like organ, novel, pencil, and lemon, unless traditional spelling would indicate a mispronunciation in SoundSpel (hence, the word mountain is spelled mounten).[6] To represent the schwi (half "ee") sound, which can be pronounced more than one way, SoundSpel has three rules: ⟨e⟩ should be used in a word's first syllable (e.g., event, eqip for equip), ⟨i⟩ should be followed by a schwa in the combinations ia, io, and iu (e.g., insomnia, joevial for jovial), and ⟨y⟩ should be used terminally, or medially when not followed by schwa a, o, and u (e.g., raedyo for radio, joevyality for joviality). Using ⟨y⟩ terminally in monosyllabic words (e.g., bee) and their derivatives (e.g., hunybee for honeybee, as opposed to hunyby) is discouraged.[8] The letter ⟨y⟩ should also be used to prevent ambiguity between graphemes, as in the words terryer (terrier) and audyens (audience), in which ⟨ie⟩ would otherwise be pronounced //.[19] According to Rondthaler and Lias, this system "combines most of the logic of Ripman['s system] with most of the visual compatibility of Dewey['s]."[20]

Unstressed ⟨er⟩, ⟨ar⟩, and ⟨or⟩ ("schwer")

Rondthaler and Lias are less decisive when it comes to spelling schwers (a portmanteau of schwa and the digraph ⟨er⟩), where a stressed rhotic vowel (i.e., /ɑːr/ and /ɔːr/) becomes unstressed (i.e., /ər/) in rapid speech. According to them, "[it was suggested that] certain unstressed syllables be abbreviated according to prescribed rules: that schwers be reduced to ⟨r⟩ (numbr, doctrd, considret, murdrr), that -tion be abbreviated to -tn or -shn [reflecting SoundSpel's -shun], etc." However, SoundSpel favors traditional spelling in these cases because, first, the reform's "immediate goal ... is to reflect a word's full pronunciation". Second, words' derivatives often contain a stressed rhotic vowel (e.g., victor, unstressed, to victorious, stressed). Keeping traditional spelling can be useful in retaining these aesthetic relationships.[21]

Exceptions

Common words and proper nouns

The following extremely common words remain irregularly spelled: as, be, do, has, he, his, she, me, we, is, of, th (the), thru (through), to, U (you), and was.[22][23] These words would otherwise be spelled az, bee, doo, haz, hee, hiz, shee, mee, wee, iz, uv/ov, thee, throo, too, ue, and wuz, respectively. Words derived from these (such as being, together, and thruout) do not alter their root, and the suffix -ful also remains unchanged. The word I, like in traditional spelling, remains capitalized. The word U, a respelling of you, does the same. As Edward Rondthaler wrote: "Since we accept the flattery of capital I for 'me', let us extend the courtesy of capital U for 'you'."[23][19] In SoundSpel's 1978 form, however, neither I nor U were capitalized.[10]

As for proper nouns, "little can be gained and much lost by pressing for reform [of proper nouns]," and so SoundSpel tends to retain their spellings (including those of personal names). However, dictionaries could still use SoundSpel to indicate an irregular proper noun's pronunciation,[24] and months and days of the week may also be respelled.[23]

Pluralization

There is no change in the plural suffix -s (as in jobs), the possessive suffix -'s (as in man's), and in the third person present singular verb suffix -s (as in he runs), even though in all these cases the s is sometimes pronounced /z/.[6] A double s can be used to distinguish these words, as in caes (cays, /keɪz/) vs. caess (case, /keɪs/). This is a break from the Dictionary of Simplified American Spelling in which plurals would be spelled purely phonetically (e.g., clooz for clues).[25] The letter ⟨x⟩ does not form the plurals of words ending with a /k/ sound. For example, the plural of dok (dock) is not dox, but doks. This follows (formal) traditional spelling.

Features

  • Relies upon common, familiar digraphs except for ⟨aa⟩, ⟨uu⟩, and ⟨zh⟩, though these are in fact seen in some words (see: aardvark, squush, zhoosh).
  • Does not dramatically change the appearance of existing words (i.e., through the use of non-Latin letters), and generally decreases text length by about 4%.[6] SoundSpel also promotes more precise pronunciation in speech.
  • Removes many doubled letters made redundant under the reform. Has virtually no silent letters.
  • Generally not intended to differentiate homophones, as "context takes care of everything [in speech, and therefore writing]."[26] However, as writing is matched with speech, many homographs differentiate, e.g., read, which becomes reed (present tense) and red (past tense).
  • Improves consistency of writing, thereby reducing learning time and reading difficulties compared to traditional English spelling.
  • Is easier to learn, and especially easier to read, for those who are familiar with traditional English spelling than other systems. However, compromises and rule exceptions make SoundSpel more difficult to learn than it would be if it were a purely phonemic system.
  • According to the Dictionary of Simplified American Spelling, "[SoundSpel] is fully compatible with traditional spelling and can be mixed with it in any proportion desired."[27]
  • The grapheme ⟨u⟩ is never used finally to represent /ə/; ⟨a⟩ is used instead. In fact, U is the only word in SoundSpel that ends with a ⟨u⟩,[28] with the possible exception of thru.

Text examples

Th Star by H. G. Wells

It was on th ferst dae of th nue yeer th anounsment was maed, allmoest siemultaeniusly frum three obzervatorys, that th moeshun of th planet Neptune, th outermoest of all planets that wheel about th Sun, had becum verry erratic. A retardaeshun in its velosity had bin suspected in Desember. Then, a faent, remoet spek of liet was discuverd in th reejon of th perterbd planet. At ferst, this did not cauz eny verry graet exsietment. Sieentific peepl, however, found th intelijens remarkabl enuf, eeven befor it becaem noen that th nue body was rapidly groeing larjer and brieter, and that its moeshun was qiet different frum th orderly progres of th planets. [657 characters]

(It was on the first day of the new year the announcement was made, almost simultaneously from three observatories, that the motion of the planet Neptune, the outermost of all planets that wheel around the sun, had become very erratic. A retardation in its velocity had been suspected in December. Then a faint, remote speck of light was discovered in the region of the perturbed planet. At first this did not cause any very great excitement. Scientific people, however, found the intelligence remarkable enough, even before it became known that the new body was rapidly growing larger and brighter, and that its motion was quiet different from the orderly progress of the planets.) [680 characters]

Britten wen yung by Frank Kermode

We mae nowadaes be chairy about uezing th werd 'jeenius', but we stil hav a guud iedeea wut is ment bi it. For exampl, thair ar graet numbers of verry gifted muezishans hoo ar admierd but not calld jeeniuses. But thair ar uthers, manifestly prodijus, performing offen at extraordinerrily erly aejes, a varieety of feets so complex that th muezical laeman cuud hardly imajin, eeven with th moest desperet laebor, acomplishing eny of them, wiel eeven muezishans ar astonisht and we then reech for th guud, handy, vaeg Enlietenment werd and call them jeeniuses. Th list incloods Mozart and Mendelssohn; and, despiet all th limiting jujments, it incloods Benjamin Britten. [668 characters]

(We may nowadays he chary about using the word ‘genius’, but we still have a good idea what is meant by it. For example, there are great numbers of very gifted musicians who are admired but not called geniuses. But there are others manifestly prodigious, performing, often at extraordinarily early ages, a variety of feats so complex that the musical layman could hardly imagine, even with the most desperate labour, accomplishing any one of them, while even musicians are astonished: and we then reach for the good, handy, vague Enlightenment word and call them geniuses. The list includes Mozart and Mendelssohn; and, despite all the limiting judgments, it includes Benjamin Britten.)[29] [684 characters]

Oed to a Nietingael by John Keats

Mi hart aeks, and a drouzy numnes paens
  Mi sens, as tho of hemlok I had drunk,
Or empteed sum dul oepiaet to th draens
  Wun minit past, and Lethe-wards had sunk;
'Tis not thru envy of thi hapy lot,
  But being too hapy in thien hapynes,—
  That thow, liet-winged Dryad of th trees,
  In sum meloedius plot
  Of beechen green, and shadoes numberles
  Singest of sumer in fuul-throeted eez. [368 characters]

(My heart aches, and a drowsy numbness pains
  My sense, as though of hemlock I had drunk,
Or emptied some dull opiate to the drains
  One minute past, and Lethe-wards had sunk:
'Tis not through envy of thy happy lot,
  But being too happy in thine happiness,—
  That thou, light-winged Dryad of the trees
  In some melodious plot
  Of beechen green, and shadows numberless,
  Singest of summer in full-throated ease.)[30] [393 characters]

See also

Notes

  1. In SoundSpel, the letters a, e, i, and o can act as "schwa vowels." See "Schwa and schwi" under "Rules".
  2. The phoneme /ɔː/ is usually spelled ⟨au⟩ or ⟨aw⟩, but the digraph ⟨ll⟩ indicates that a preceding ⟨a⟩ is pronounced /ɔː/,[6] as in fall, tall, and call, which would otherwise be spelled faul, taul, and caul, respectively. Likewise, an ⟨o⟩ before two f's (e.g., offer) or two s's (cross), and most of time before an ⟨ng⟩ (long, strong) is pronounced /ɔː/.[7]
  3. At a word's end, the phonemes (//) and (//) may be written without an ⟨e⟩, as in go and fli, but non-final vowels require an ⟨e⟩. Hence: banjo and its plural banjoes. An ⟨e⟩ should also be used to distinguish from irregularly spelled words. For example, the word toe should retain its ⟨e⟩ as to prevent confusion with the word to. Early versions of SoundSpel also recommended retaining an ⟨e⟩ to indicate stress. For instance, the word bellow was spelled belo to indicate first-syllable stress, and the ⟨e⟩ was reintroduced to indicate second-syllable stress in the word below, spelled beloe.[8]
  4. As it is "asking too much... of readers of English" to transition fully to one grapheme per pronunciation, these digraphs are governed by two rules. ⟨ou⟩ and ⟨au⟩ are always followed by a consonant and never end a root or a word (e.g., oul for traditional owl, aukward for awkward). ⟨ow⟩ and ⟨aw⟩ never begin a word (e.g., plowing, flawd for flawed). Though these examples are exceptional, these rules are intended to bring SoundSpel closer to traditional spelling.[9]
  5. In earlier forms of SoundSpel,[10][11] the grapheme ⟨ur⟩ represented /ɜːr/ as to help differentiate and indicate stress in certain words, as in convert (noun) vs. convurt (verb). More recently, ⟨ur⟩ and ⟨er⟩ represent different sounds altogether.[12]
  6. The grapheme ⟨k⟩ is used before the letters e, i, and y (e.g., keebord for keyboard, kil for kill, and munky for monkey) and when definitively ending closed syllables (e.g., qik for quick, bakpak for backpack). The grapheme ⟨k⟩ can also be used to maintain the consistent spelling of roots when Inflections and Suffixes are added (e.g., qikly for quickly). The grapheme ⟨c⟩ is used in all other cases.[13] These rules are used to prevent French-like pronunciations.
  7. Though it is not likely that this digraph has been formally adopted by SoundSpel, one of the system's predecessors, Ripman's and Archer's New Spelling, recommends it.[14] This digraph would not be applicable to many English dialects outside of interjections and loanwords.
  8. As to retain the regularity of inflected words with final syllabic consonants, SoundSpel follows traditional spelling. Whenever a schwa vowel separates a word's final consonants (e.g. pedal) the vowel is retained (hence, the inflected form pedaling). Otherwise, it is dropped (e.g. rithm, hence rithmik).[15]
  9. Before the letters k, q, and x.
  10. The digraph ⟨th⟩ can be pronounced as unvoiced /θ/ or voiced /ð/. Spelling reformers have suggested using thh or dh (from edh) to represent the /ð/ sound, but SoundSpel reluctantly rejects both "in the interest of visual compatibility [with traditional spelling]."[16] Additionally, unvoiced occurrences of ⟨th⟩ outnumber the voiced 5 to 1.[6]
  11. Per 1986 rules,[17] when the letter ⟨x⟩ is followed by a vowel, it is pronounced /gz/ (e.g., exam, exult). Otherwise, it is pronounced /ks/ (expect, fox). When a vowel follows a /ks/ pronunciation, SoundSpel inserts an ⟨s⟩ after the ⟨x⟩ (axsis for axis, exsodus for exodus) so that the rule holds. However, in 1999 Rondthaler wrote that ⟨x⟩ can represent both /ks/ and /gz/, which would make spelling less phonemic but would not require the ⟨s⟩ rule.

References

McGehee, Robert J. (2021). "Short answer to Mario, in response to the comment originally addressed to Mark Petersen".

Petersen, Mark. "A Message from the President". Los Alamos, New Mexico.

Ripman, Walter; Archer, William (1948). New Spelling (PDF) (6 ed.).

Rondthaler, Edward; Lias, Edward J. (1978). "SoundSpel: A revised orthography of the English language". New York: Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers.

Rondthaler, Edward; Lias, Edward J. (1986). Dictionary of American Spelling: A Simplified Alternative Spelling for the English Language. New York: The American Language Academy.

Rondthaler, Edward (1999). "SoundSpel [TM]" (PDF). English Spelling Society.

This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.