Parachute candidate
A parachute candidate (also known as a "carpetbagger" in the United States) is a pejorative term[1] for an election candidate who does not live in, and has little connection to, the area they are running to represent. The allegation is thus that the candidate is being “parachuted in” for the job by a desperate political party that has no reliable talent local to the district or state or that the party (or the candidate himself/herself) wishes to give a candidate an easier election than would happen in one's own home area.
Part of the Politics series |
Elections |
---|
![]() |
![]() |
Australia
- In 2004, musician and activist Peter Garrett was preselected as the Australian Labor Party candidate for the safe seat of Kingsford Smith due to the intervention of leader Mark Latham, despite opposition from the local ALP branch, who labelled him an outsider. The CFMEU issued a statement criticising his selection as "a pathetic version of political celebrity squares".[2]
- In 2007, journalist Maxine McKew was preselected as Labor candidate for Bennelong, held by then-Prime Minister John Howard. McKew did not live in the electorate at the time, and sold her home in Mosman to move prior to the election. She went on to defeat Howard, becoming the first candidate to unseat a sitting Prime Minister in an election since 1929.[2]
- In 2013, Liberal National Senator Barnaby Joyce was preselected as Liberal candidate for the seat of New England. Joyce was raised in Tamworth, within the electorate, but lived had lived in Queensland for over twenty years, and represented the state in the Senate since 2005.[2]
- In 2013, athlete Nova Peris was preselected as Labor's leading candidate for the Senate in the Northern Territory. Peris was born and raised in the Northern Territory, but her selection was received with controversy due to her celebrity status and the personal intervention of leader and Prime Minister Julia Gillard, who described the selection as "captain's pick."[2]
- After the resignation of Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull from parliament in 2018, Dave Sharma was preselected as the Liberal candidate in the resulting by-election. Sharma did not live in the electorate at the time. He narrowly lost the by-election, but successfully contested the seat again several months later in the 2019 federal election.[2]
- Georgina Downer was Liberal candidate for the electorate of Mayo in the 2018 by-election. Daughter of long-serving MP for Mayo Alexander Downer, Downer had grown up in the area and proclaimed that she was "coming home" in the by-election. However, she had lived most of her life in Adelaide and Melbourne, and sought preselection for a seat in the latter during the 2016 election. She lost to incumbent Rebekha Sharkie.[2]
- Jane Garrett, a former minister in the First Andrews Ministry in Victoria was parachuted into the number one position in the Eastern Victoria Region at the 2018 Victorian state election, a seat vacated by future MP Daniel Mulino for the Division of Fraser in Melbourne's western suburbs. Garrett had been the MP for the Electoral district of Brunswick which was becoming increasingly marginal and was criticised for her role in a dispute between the Country Fire Authority, the United Firefighters Union and the state government in her capacity as Minister for Emergency Services.[3][4]
- Daniel Mulino is the current MP for the Division of Fraser in Melbourne's western suburbs. Mulino had previously been a Member of the Victorian Legislative Council for the Eastern Victoria Region, a seat he vacated for Jane Garrett. Prior to his tenure in the Parliament of Victoria, Mulino was a councillor and mayor for the City of Casey. Mulino did not live in the electorate of Fraser up until the 2019 Australian federal election where he was elected.
- Former Premier of New South Wales Kristina Keneally was preselected as Labor candidate for 2017 Bennelong by-election. She lived 800 metres outside the electorate which, combined her high profile, attracted accusations of parachuting.[2]
- Keneally sought preselection for the House of Representatives again in 2021, this time for the electorate of Fowler in western Sydney despite living in the northern suburbs. She was also criticised for making the move despite outgoing member Chris Hayes having already endorsed local lawyer Tu Le as his successor.[5][6]
- Former President of the Australian Labor Party Warren Mundine was a parachute candidate for the Liberal Party of Australia in the Division of Gilmore at the 2019 Australian federal election to succeed retiring MP Ann Sudmalis. Prior to Mundine's selection, the local party branches had preselected Grant Schultz, whose candidacy would eventually be overridden by the party's state executive to select Mundine instead at the request of prime minister Scott Morrison.[7][8] Mundine would be defeated by Fiona Phillips of the Australian Labor Party who received a two-party swing of 3.34 per cent while Schultz contested the electorate as an independent candidate, receiving 7,585 votes.
- There is no legal requirement that inhibits parachute candidates, who may reside in another state as well as another seat.
Canada
- Chrystia Freeland faced allegations of being parachuted in by the Liberal Party to contest a 2013 by-election in safe seat Toronto Centre, given she was living in New York City at the time. She ultimately won the seat.[9]
- In 2008, the New Democratic Party nominated Phyllis Artiss of St. John's for the riding of Labrador. Artiss was nominated in the absence of any local candidate, and admitted that her candidacy was not ideal: "It would be much better to have someone from Labrador who has lived there all their lives or much of their lives and worked there, and I haven't done that."[1]
- Kellie Leitch was accused of being a parachute candidate when she sought the Conservative nomination in the riding of Simcoe-Grey in Ontario. Leitch was born in Winnipeg, Manitoba and worked in Toronto at the time of her nomination.[10][11]
- Patrick Brown, who had previously been MP for Barrie and MPP for Simcoe North, was criticized as a parachute candidate when he announced his campaign for Mayor of Brampton in 2018.[12] Brown ultimately was successful in his mayoral bid.[13]
New Zealand
- In 2017 Deborah Russell won selection for the safe Labour seat of New Lynn, in south-east Auckland despite being from Whangamōmona, a small town in the Manawatū-Whanganui region. She beat out Greg Presland a New Lynn resident for 30 years who had the backing of the local members but lost to Russell who was backed by Labour's Council because of her finance expertise and a pledge to have more women in electorates. Upon winning selection Russell moved to the electorate.[14][15]
Republic of Ireland
- Avril Doyle stood for Fine Gael at the 2004 European elections in the Ireland East constituency, despite being from Dublin, and was considered a parachute candidate.[16]
- George Lee was a successful parachute candidate for Fine Gael at the 2009 Dublin South by-election.[17]
- Journalist Susan O'Keeffe was described as a parachute candidate by local candidate Veronica Cawley when she stood for Labour in Sligo–North Leitrim at the 2011 general election; O'Keeffe is a native of Dublin but lived in Sligo at the time.[18][19][20]
- Lorraine Mulligan was described as a parachute candidate when she stood for Labour at the 2014 Dublin West by-election, despite living in Dublin Central.[21]
- Catherine Noone stood for Fine Gael in Dublin West at the 2016 general election; she later attempted to be "parachuted" in Dublin South-West before standing in Dublin Bay North at the 2020 general election.[22]
- Sheila Nunan stood for the Labour at the 2019 European elections in the Ireland South constituency, despite living in Dublin. Her team replied that she lived near the border with County Wicklow and her parents are from County Kerry, both counties located in the South constituency.[23][24] Michael McNamara claimed that "a parachute candidate could look like desperation. We [the Labour Party] need to be relevant and have ideas that are relevant to people in rural Ireland."[25]
United Kingdom
Parachute candidates are common in the Parliament of the United Kingdom. The Westminster system historically emphasizes party discipline over responsiveness to constituencies. Margaret Thatcher represented Finchley despite living in Chelsea, London.[26]
A 2013 YouGov survey found that support for a hypothetical candidate rose by 12 points after voters learned that his opponent had moved to the area two years earlier, and by 30 points if the opponent lived 120 miles away. The percentage of local MPs rose, according to Michael Rush of the University of Exeter, from 25% in 1979 to 45% in 1997; Ralph Scott of Demos calculates that as of 2014 63% are local.[26]
According to surveys public trust in all MPs has decreased but trust in the local MP has increased, making pre-existing connections to seats more important. Election advertisements mention the candidate's party or party leader less often, and emphasize local connections. Such a change produces MPs that are more attentive to local issues, but may be detrimental to Britain's first-past-the-post system designed to create broad parties that party whips stabilize.[26]
- Roy Jenkins was so unfamiliar with Glasgow, he later wrote, that on arrival to campaign for the 1982 Glasgow Hillhead by-election its skyline was "as mysterious to me as the minarets of Constantinople" to Russian troops during the Russo-Turkish War.[26] Jenkins won the election, taking the seat from the Scottish Conservatives.[27]
- Shaun Woodward defected from the Conservative Party to the Labour Party in 1999. He faced much criticism from former Conservative colleagues, particularly when he refused to resign and fight a by-election.[28][29] Woodward did not run for re-election in his safe Conservative seat of Witney in Oxfordshire, instead being selected for the ultra-safe Labour seat of St Helens South in Merseyside. Labour Minister Chris Mullin wrote later in his diaries that "the New Labour elite parachuting [Woodward] into a safe seat ... [was] one of New Labour's vilest stitch-ups ... [it] made my flesh creep."[30]
- Luciana Berger was an example of Labour parachuting a middle-class southerner into one of its traditional heartland seats, in her case the northern working-class safe seat of Liverpool Wavertree. She was heavily criticised for having no connection to the Wavertree constituency or Liverpool when she first ran in 2010. When asked by a local radio station to answer basic questions about Liverpool she was unable to, and during the candidate selection process stayed at local MP Jane Kennedy's house rather than make any permanent home in the area. The media raised suggestions that she was only selected for the seat because of her close connections to the Blair family.[31] She went on to win the seat in 2010 and retain it in 2015 and 2017. After joining the Liberal Democrats in 2019, she unsuccessfully contested the Greater London seat of Finchley and Golders Green in the 2019 general election. She made the decision to stand there because of the seat's high Jewish population and Remain vote, as well as her affinity towards living in London and choice to raise her children there, rather than in Liverpool.[32][33]
- David and Ed Miliband were selected to fight safe Labour seats in northern England, South Shields and Doncaster North respectively, despite being Oxford graduates who were born, raised, and living in London whilst working as political advisers. Both would later serve as cabinet ministers and fight against each other in the 2010 party leadership election.
- Douglas Carswell defected from the Conservatives to the UK Independence Party in 2014, in turn displacing the existing UKIP candidate in his constituency of Clacton. Given Carswell was living in London at the time, he was accused carpetbagging by the former UKIP candidate.[34]
- George Galloway was expelled from Labour in 2003 and, despite previously representing Glasgow Kelvin, did not contest a Glasgow seat in 2005. Instead, he stood for the Respect Party in the Greater London constituency of Bethnal Green and Bow, where he used his opposition to the Iraq War and the local Muslim population to gain the seat from Labour. Tottenham MP and Constitutional Affairs Minister David Lammy said he was a carpetbagger who had whipped up racial tensions.[35] After standing down from Bethnal Green and Bow in 2010, he had a two-year hiatus from parliament. In a 2012 by-election, he stood for Respect in the West Yorkshire seat of Bradford West, also with a high local Muslim population, where he made a point of not drinking and again gained the seat from Labour.[36] He lost Bradford West in 2015 to Labour's Naz Shah, after a divisive campaign.[37] Since then, he has made further attempts to parachute himself into constituencies in order to return to parliament. As an independent, he unsuccessfully contested Manchester Gorton in 2017 and West Bromwich East in 2019.[38][39] He also attempted to be selected as the Brexit Party candidate in the Cambridgeshire seat of Peterborough in a 2019 by-election, but the party selected local businessman Mike Greene.[40][41]
United States
U.S. Senate
- Former U.S. Senator Scott Brown ran unsuccessfully as a Republican for U.S. Senate in 2014 in New Hampshire, despite having previously represented Massachusetts in the Senate as recently as two years prior. Brown's family had previously resided in New Hampshire, and he personally owns a vacation home in the state.
- Former Reagan administration diplomat Alan Keyes, a resident of Maryland, ran unsuccessfully as a Republican during the 2004 Illinois U.S. Senate election.[42] Notably, he had previously made two unsuccessful runs for the Senate in Maryland.
- First Lady Hillary Clinton was elected to the Senate from New York in 2000 after having bought a house in Chappaqua, New York (a wealthy suburb of New York City) in 1999, prior to the election. She had previously resided in Illinois and Arkansas.
- Former U.S. Attorney General Robert F. Kennedy was elected to the U.S. Senate in New York in 1964, serving from 1965 until his death on June 6, 1968. He had previously resided in his home state of Massachusetts, although as a child he had also lived in the New York City neighborhood of Riverdale as well as Bronxville, a suburb north of New York City. During the campaign, Kennedy gave a speech in response to criticisms from his opponents over his alleged lack of ties to the state.
- Former 2012 presidential candidate Mitt Romney was elected Senator of Utah in 2018, despite previously being Governor of Massachusetts.
U.S. House of Representatives
- Former Maryland State Senator and Maryland Republican Party Chairman Alex Mooney was elected in 2014 to represent West Virginia's 2nd congressional district in the U.S. House of Representatives.[43]
- Businessman Trey Hollingsworth moved from Tennessee to Indiana in September 2015. He ran as a Republican to represent Indiana's 9th congressional district in the U.S. House of Representatives, and won the election in 2016.[44]
References
- "NDP criticized for running parachute candidate in Labrador". CBC News. 19 September 2008. Retrieved 24 Feb 2015.
- "Fly in, fly out: a guide to parachute candidates". Crikey. 1 February 2019.
- "Victorian minister Jane Garrett resigns from Cabinet as Government seeks to end CFA dispute". ABC News. 9 June 2016. Retrieved 11 June 2016.
- Towell, Noel (24 July 2018). "Garrett takes the long and winding road to the far east". The Age.
- Glenday, James; Haydar, Nour (9 September 2021). "Kristina Keneally's swap into safe Western Sydney seat sparks anger among Labor locals". Australian Broadcasting Corporation. Sydney, New South Wales. Retrieved 2021-09-10.
- Harris, Rob (10 September 2021). "Keneally vows to 'step up and fight' as Labor brawls over lower house move". Sydney Morning Herald. Sydney, New South Wales. Retrieved 2021-09-10.
- Gerathy, Sarah; Norman, Jane (22 January 2019). "Warren Mundine installed as Gilmore candidate at behest of Prime Minister". Australian Broadcasting Corporation. Retrieved 2021-09-15.
- Koziol, Michael (22 January 2019). "Scott Morrison to parachute former Labor boss Warren Mundine into marginal seat". Canberra Times. Retrieved 2021-09-15.
- "John Ivison: Justin Trudeau parachutes 'star' candidate Chrystia Freeland into safe Toronto Centre".
- "Tim Harper: Conservative civil war engulfing Helena Guergis' riding". thestar.com. 2011-04-18. Retrieved 2020-10-19.
- "How Kellie Leitch touched off a culture war - Macleans.ca". www.macleans.ca. Retrieved 2020-10-19.
- "Patrick Brown begins campaign to rise from political ashes in Brampton mayoral race | CBC News". CBC. Retrieved 2020-10-19.
- "Patrick Brown defeats incumbent Linda Jeffrey to become mayor of Brampton". Global News. Retrieved 2020-10-19.
- Trevett, Claire (25 January 2017). "Battle to replace Labour's David Cunliffe in New Lynn heats up". The New Zealand Herald.
- Ali, Mahvash (6 March 2017). "The "Taranaki girl" who wants to win over New Lynn". Stuff.
- "Running 'mates' ready for prize fight". Irish Examiner. April 26, 2004.
- O'Regan, Michael. "FG may opt for high-profile byelection candidate". The Irish Times.
- "Labour row over candidate choice in Sligo-N Leitrim - Indymedia Ireland". www.indymedia.ie.
- "PressReader.com - Your favorite newspapers and magazines". www.pressreader.com.
- "Political Platform: Senator Susan O'Keeffe". May 9, 2014.
- "Labour candidate hoping enthusiasm wins her votes". The Irish Independent. 19 May 2014.
- "CATHERINE NOONE'S DÁIL AMBITION". The Phoenix Magazine. 1 March 2018.
- "FG's Doyle selected to run in European elections". Irish Examiner. 4 March 2019.
- "Nunan defends constituency links after ex-TD's online posts". The Irish Independent. 7 May 2019.
- Kelly, Fiach (8 January 2019). "Labour lines up outgoing INTO boss to stand in European elections". The Irish Times.
- "No more parachuting in". The Economist. 2014-12-11. ISSN 0013-0613. Retrieved 2020-07-08.
- Boothroyd, David. "Results of Byelections in the 1979-83 Parliament". United Kingdom Election Results. Archived from the original on June 9, 2000. Retrieved 2015-09-19.
- "Fallout grows over Tory turncoat". BBC News. 20 December 1999. Archived from the original on 13 April 2014. Retrieved 12 April 2014.
- "Top Tory defects to Labour". The Guardian. 19 December 1999. Archived from the original on 13 April 2014. Retrieved 12 April 2012.
- Chris Mullin (2009). A View From The Foothills: The Diaries of Chris Mullin. ISBN 978-1-84668-223-0.
- "Crash landing for Labour candidate parachuted into Liverpool". The Independent. 23 April 2010.
- "Luciana Berger to stand for Lib Dems in Finchley and Golders Green". www.thejc.com. Retrieved 2019-10-01.
- "Lib Dems recruit Luciana Berger to stand in north London seat". Evening Standard. 2019-09-26. Retrieved 2019-10-01.
- "'Douglas Carswell is a gutless coward' says ousted UKIP candidate Roger Lord".
- Lammy, David (5 May 2005). BBC Election 2005. Event occurs at 6:57:50.
I think he's a carpetbagger who came down from Scotland to whip up racial tensions in Tower Hamlets.
- Gilligan, Andrew (2012-03-30). "A runaway victory for George Galloway – and all praise to Allah". Daily Telegraph. ISSN 0307-1235. Retrieved 2019-06-29.
- Sky News (2015-05-10), Special Report: The Battle For Bradford West, archived from the original on 2021-12-12, retrieved 2019-06-29
- "Manchester Gorton parliamentary constituency - Election 2017". Retrieved 2019-06-29.
- "West Bromwich East parliamentary constituency - Election 2019". Retrieved 2019-12-13.
- "Brexit candidates may split Peterborough vote after jailed MP ousted". Evening Standard. 2019-05-02. Retrieved 2019-06-29.
- "Secret Millionaire Mike Greene revealed as Brexit Party Peterborough by-election candidate". www.peterboroughtoday.co.uk. Retrieved 2019-06-29.
- "Illinois GOP offers Senate nod to Alan Keyes". CNN. August 5, 2004.
- Strauss, Daniel (February 14, 2014). "Meet The Carpetbagging Tea Partier Who Could Be W. Va.'s Newest Rep". Talking Points Memo.
- Evans, Tim; Alesia, Mark (April 25, 2016). "Trey Hollingsworth for Congress — rich carpetbagger or breath of fresh air?". The Indianapolis Star.