Outlaster

Recording sessions for the album took place over the course of four days at Steve Albini's Electrical Audio in Chicago, from March 9 to March 12, 2009.[2] Several songs on Outlaster were performed live prior to their inclusion on the album. "Cry, Cry, Baby" was performed in December 2002 on John Peel's BBC Radio 1 show, under the title "Cry Baby".[3] Similarly, "You Can Take Your Time" was performed during Nastasia's June 2004 Peel Session with Tuvan throat singing group Huun-Huur-Tu.[4] The Outlaster version of "You Can Take Your Time" was first released almost a year prior to the album being issued; the song appeared on the 2009 edition of FatCat Records's annual sampler in August 2009.[5][6]

Although no record producer is listed in the album credits, Nastasia's manager Kennan Gudjonsson is listed as the album's "musical director".[7] Paul Bryan, who arranged and conducted the album's orchestral and woodwind instrumentation, confirmed Gudjonsson as the "de facto" producer of the record. In his recording diary, Bryan said the band and orchestral quartet completed the album's backing tracks in the first three days. He elaborated that "things got off to an alarmingly slow start, but we eventually fell into a groove; I would rehearse the strings while Nina, Jay and Jeff would fool around with ideas. Once I felt we were ready to track, I would grab a bass and hope that we could pull off something usable while the tape was still rolling." Bryan's piano and the woodwind quartet were overdubbed on the fourth day, with Albini completing the mixing of the record that same night. Bryan said "It was an intense four days and really fun."[2]

The album artwork was created by Dave Thomas, under the pseudonym "DLT", and Kennan Gudjonsson. The two collaborated on the artwork for Nastasia's previous two albums – 2006's On Leaving and 2007's You Follow Me – with Thomas saying Gudjonsson "loved packaging, he loved the artwork side of things." Gudjonsson created the illustration, with the two going "back and forth about the typography" and Gudjonsson hand rendering the final image. Thomas remarked that because of Gudjonsson's "attention to detail, a lot of people said he was quite difficult to work with, but I love going into that level of detail as well, so it was a real joy to work with him. There was always that thing of like, I've not thought of going quite that detailed on it. Like, the [CD booklets] for all of Nina's releases have little round corners on them because Kennan loved round corners. It's something that you would never see if you didn't buy the CD version to those records."[8]

Album track "You're a Holy Man" was offered as a free download by Clash on March 31, 2010.[9] A music video for "Cry, Cry, Baby" was released on April 13. The film was directed by Theo Stanley, and consisted of an unedited panoramic shot of the song being performed live in Nastasia's Chelsea, Manhattan apartment.[10] On May 4, album track "What's Out There" premiered on Stereogum, which described the track as "dramatic" and "ambitious", saying "the piece is gleefully exploding at the seems."[11] Clash launched a competition that same day, where the winner received a vinyl copy of the album, as well as a tote bag and a screen print of the album artwork.[12] A limited run of these items were also sold at Nastasia's official web store.[13]

"Cry, Cry, Baby" was issued as the first single from Outlaster on May 10, as a download-only release,[14] and contained an exclusive b-side, the intimate demo recording "Our Gang".[15] Nastasia began a ten-date tour of the United Kingdom on May 22.[14][16] While performing in Manchester on May 25, Nastasia and touring violinist Matt Szemela recorded an acoustic session for Marc Riley's program on BBC Radio 6 Music, conducting a brief interview and performing three tracks from the album: "Wakes", "Outlaster" and "This Familiar Way".[17] The version of the album sold at iTunes contained an exclusive pre-order bonus track titled "I'monamotherfuckingboat".[18][19]

On September 28, an acoustic session recorded by Nastasia and Szemela was published on RockFeedBack, which featured an interview and four live tracks: "Outlaster", "Cry, Cry, Baby", "What's Out There" and "I Go with Him".[20] Nastasia began the second leg of the tour supporting the album three days later.[21] Beginning in Lisbon on October 1,[22] and continuing throughout Europe,[23][24] the tour was scheduled to travel through the United Kingdom and Ireland from November 29 to December 10,[25][26] with Sons of Noel and Adrian set to appear as the opening act.[27] However, the final twelve dates of the tour – the United Kingdom and Ireland dates – were canceled, citing unspecified "health concerns."[28] "You Can Take Your Time" was released as the second single from the album on December 6, and was backed by another exclusive b-side: "One Turned In".[27]

Professional ratings

Aggregate scores
Source	Rating
AnyDecentMusic?	7.0/10[29]
Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[30]
BBC Music	Positive[31]
Drowned in Sound	8/10[32]
musicOMH	[33]
The New York Times	Positive[34]
NME	[35]
Paste	6.9/10[36]
Pitchfork	8.1/10[37]
The Skinny	[38]
Tiny Mix Tapes	[39]

Outlaster received generally positive reviews from music critics. At AnyDecentMusic?, which assigns a normalized rating out of 10 to reviews from mainstream critics, the album received an average score of 7.0 out of 10.[29] It received an average score of 74 out of 100 at Album of the Year, based on 10 reviews.[40]

Several publications praised the quality of the orchestration, including NME, which said Outlaster featured the richest and most grandiose instrumentation of her career, and describing it as one of her most accomplished works to date.[35] Similarly, musicOMH said the orchestration was distinctive when compared with the rest of Nastasia's primarily sparse work, and that the record was "impressive in artistry and accomplishment."[33] Pitchfork described the album as sounding like the result of a collaboration between a multitude of musicians "listening closely and reacting to one another", saying the collaboration prompted Nastasia to sing in a more passionate way than she had on previous records.[37] Cokemachineglow said Outlaster excised simple "quiet–loud–quiet constructions" in favor of instrumentation that swells and contracts "around the space between notes." Their writer went on to summarize that the album is "something so far beyond its parts ... beyond anyone else working within this genre."[41] The List said it was a beautiful record that was "more often than not shiver-inducing".[42]

Other writers commended the quality of Nastasia's vocals and songwriting, including The Line of Best Fit,[43] and Treblezine, which dubbed it the album of the week.[44] Although AllMusic also praised Bryan's arrangements and the orchestration, they highlighted Nastasia's vocals, saying her voice consistently rose above the arrangements "like a storm ... the effect is riveting."[30] Blurt rated the album 8 out of 10 and said Nastasia incorporated an "extraordinary variety and drama into her [vocal] delivery. Now trilling, now whispering, now belting, she has a strong sense for when to use excess and when to cut back to nothing."[1] The North Coast Journal said her vocals and delivery had more of an impact on the songs than the orchestration, and compared Nastasia's lyricism to that of Leonard Cohen.[45] BBC Music said Nastasia's "beautiful voice is at the heart of this, being easy to love and full of natural soul, but also handling every syllable with a quick-smart economy that teems with strength and authority." Their writer also praised Nastasia's songwriting, saying: "Let her stories into your life, and they will never leave you. After all, Nastasia's talent is to snare those who find her, and never let them go."[31]

Ben Ratliff of The New York Times praised the production, calling the album "ultra-suspenseful", elaborating: "The point of a Nina Nastasia record ... is that there's something threatening right over your shoulder: a sudden dynamic shift, a wail out of a whisper, drumming that trickles into a violent clatter. Her signature sound, beyond her clear, unaffected voice, is the worry in the air around the notes."[34] Similarly, BBC Music commented that the production evokes a sense of "imminent danger",[31] Drowned in Sound said it was Nastasia's most lushly-produced record to date before summarizing: "Indeed if it wasn't for the fact that Nastasia is so consistent, you'd be tempted suggest that here she has reached an expressive and creative peak. I suspect however that Nastasia's talent will continue to outlast that of her peers for a little while longer yet."[32]

In a more mixed review, Paste complained that there was too much musical variety on the record, claiming that as a result the album felt bipolar. Their writer made several other references to mental illness when elaborating on the album's lyrical content, saying that despite containing several beautiful songs, Outlaster "stretches too far in either direction; trying to encompass both naïve optimism and full-on straightjacket crazy. Maybe Nastasia's gotten tired of her nuanced tales, or maybe this album is an even more post-modern take on the real effects of mental imbalance over time—ambivalence and exhaustion." They called "What's Out There" the most "paranoid" and "downright terrifying" song in Nastasia's discography.[36] The Skinny also gave a mixed review, describing "You Can Take Your Time" as "dreary".[38] Tiny Mix Tapes said that Nastasia's records often explore the "darker shades of discontent", hypothesizing that Outlaster examines the "perils of 'outings' undertaken by the emotionally fragile". They described it as a courageous record, one that "underlines the point that human beings can persevere long enough to 'outlast' most crises", and called it a "complex and rewarding album, despite its flaws."[39]

All songs written and composed by Nina Nastasia.

Credits adapted from the liner notes of Outlaster.[7]

• Recorded at Electrical Audio in Chicago by Steve Albini
• Mastered by John and JJ Golden at Golden Mastering in Ventura, California

Musicians

Technical personnel

• Steve Albini – recording and mixing
• Paul Bryan – orchestral and woodwind arrangements and conducting
• Kennan Gudjonsson – album artwork and musical director
• Dave Thomas (as "DLT") – album artwork
• Dylan Willemsa – arrangement on "What's Out There" (with Paul Bryan)